Dead Internet Theory Has Invaded the Job Market — And Small Business Has an Advantage
Contributed by SBOC Member:
Pat Miller
Founder of the Small Business Owners Community
This content was first released in the new Small Business Summary Newsletter. Subscribe below to get insights like this straight to your inbox!
The Numbers Are Wild
Two statistics collided on today’s show and painted a picture of a job market that’s gone completely sideways:
- 40% of businesses say they can’t find skilled candidates
- 79% of job seekers are using AI to write their applications
Read that again. Businesses can’t find people. People are applying everywhere. And nobody can figure out why the system is broken.
We can. It’s Dead Internet Theory — except now it’s real life.
What Is Dead Internet Theory?
Dead Internet Theory is the idea that most of the content on the internet is generated by bots talking to other bots, with very few real humans in the loop. It started as a conspiracy theory. It’s becoming less theoretical by the day.
Now apply that to the job market:
- AI writes the job description (HR uses AI tools to draft postings)
- AI writes the resume and cover letter (79% of applicants)
- AI sifts the applications (ATS systems with AI scoring)
- AI conducts initial screening (chatbot interviews)
Nobody’s real. AI is talking to AI, and both sides are wondering why nothing works.
Why This Is Actually Good News for Small Business
While enterprise companies are trapped in the AI-to-AI loop, small business owners have something they don’t: the ability to be human.
You can:
- Skip the AI resume stack entirely. Meet people. Have a real conversation.
- Ask real questions that AI can’t prep for. “Tell me about a time you messed up and what you learned” hits different face to face.
- Hire for character over keywords. An ATS can’t measure work ethic, curiosity, or cultural fit. You can.
- Build relationships before you have an opening. The best hires come from your network, not a job board.
The companies that win the talent war won’t have the best AI recruiting tools. They’ll have the best relationships.
Your Small Business Hiring Guide
If you’re a small business owner struggling to hire:
- Stop relying on job boards as your primary strategy. They’re flooded with AI-generated noise.
- Invest in your network. Your next great hire is probably one conversation away from someone you already know.
- Make your hiring process human. Phone calls, coffee meetings, working sessions. Let people show you who they are.
- Sell your company, not just the role. Small businesses offer things corporations can’t: impact, autonomy, direct access to leadership. Lead with that.
The Dead Internet Job Market is a problem for big companies with big systems. For small businesses willing to be real, it’s an opening.
From Businessing with Pat Miller — a daily live show for small business owners. Mon–Thu at 11am CT. Join the conversation at smallbusinesscommunity.com.
Subscribe to the Small Business Summary!
Contributed by
Pat Miller
Founder of the Small Business Owners Community
Pat spent two decades in broadcasting management and hosting. After leaving the radio industry, he spent time consulting small businesses and realized the support system for entrepreneurs was broken. Where could you find help for improving small businesses and building real connections with other like-minded people. In June of 2020, the Idea Collective Small Business Community was born.